Peter Atkinson, who was one of the four other hardy Bees who walked from Brentford to Hartlepool with me in February 2005, puts pen to paper to share his personal views in light of some some of the social media comments made following last weekend’s defeat to Brighton.
We are a club in transition – a club that is evolving from long-time obscurity towards becoming a household name. This transition is never going to be a smooth one for anyone, be it off the pitch, on the pitch or in the stands. We are all learning together how this evolution affects the club we love and, as with any learning process, mistakes will be made. Learning from these mistakes is the key to success though and if we can all keep moving forward in the same direction, together, then we can all reap the benefits as we make progress.
Now that may all sound like wishy-washy crap when you’ve had to endure a frustratingly toothless and ultimately expensive game away at Brighton on a Friday night for a game that was inconveniently moved for TV (to those 1100-odd Bees fans, you have my utmost admiration), but it’s important to remember where we’ve come from and where we’re going to. No-one wants to go back to how things were before, do they?
Recently there seems to be an increasing level of criticism aimed at the club’s strategy in the transfer market. Let’s not forget though that we are still a selling club along with 95% of the rest of the clubs in the football pyramid. We simply cannot hold onto our players when they are tempted by bigger, richer clubs, as has always been the case. Last season put them well and truly in the shop window, so it’s no great surprise that we’ve now lost five or six of the regulars from that team. The big difference now though is that we have the clout and the nous to be able to fight our corner and get the best price for our players. Gone are the days of losing our best players for peanuts and leaving a gaping hole in the team (Gayle, Grainger, Forster, Mahon, Smith, Campbell, Turner to name but a few) but at least now we can hold our own and force the arms of the poachers into paying top dollar or shuffling off to find their next victim.
Until we have our new stadium and have spent a few more seasons in the Championship, this is probably the best that we can hope for, and any thoughts of being able to offer wage-structure-shattering contracts to a player who is looking elsewhere anyway are simply foolish. That only leads to a spiralling wage bill as existing and new players want parity with the superstar and then we’re in seriously dangerous territory. Evolution takes time and, whilst the temptation is to try to run before we can walk, I would rather take ten years to see the club I love reach the Promised Land as a stable entity than gamble it all on a massive extravaganza that could (and most likely, would) ultimately fail and see us plummet. Put simply, from the past decade I’d rather be Swansea than Portsmouth.
Some people talk about the club only being interested in making profit from the players, having an unhealthy obsession with the balance sheet as we buy ‘em cheap and sell ‘em big. Well quite frankly, why not!? That’s how we generate the money to grow the club, because for a club our size at Griffin Park we don’t have the revenue streams elsewhere to do that. It comes from clever buying and calculated selling. Yes it disrupts the squad, yes it may scupper our outside chances of the play-offs this season, but you have to look at the bigger picture. We always used to scratch around, desperately hoping to unearth a hidden gem that we could sell to keep the club afloat (thank goodness for DJ). Now we have an extensive scouting network that can actively source and buy in quality players who are almost guaranteed to earn us a few million quid profit within the space of a season or two as they develop and we benefit from their performances on the pitch. And hey, when they move on, we know we’ll almost certainly have an even brighter star to replace them with. I know which of those scenarios I prefer.
Whilst Matthew Benham is in charge, I have no worries about our status as a Championship club being under threat. As far as recruitment goes, mistakes were made last summer. These have been admitted and I genuinely think they will have been learnt from. But whilst we may have been a little Continental-heavy at the start of the season and we’re still a few players light after recent departures, by the end of the season our young squad will have another year of experience and a good six months of being moulded into the side that Dean Smith wants. If we can add to the squad with another four or five smart signings, I have no doubt we can have another play-off push next season.
So let’s not get too downhearted because of the current poor run of form and a few changes around the club. You can’t have silver linings without a few clouds as well. Let’s not let the multitude of ignoramuses in the media who spout drivel about the way our club is run have any sort of satisfaction from sensing any dissatisfaction in our ranks. Our club is on the up, for good this time. We are no one-season-wonders. We no longer have to pin our hopes on the likes of Fola Onibuje or Neil Shipperley. Whatever our opinions, we all have red and white blood running through our veins. Goodness knows we’ve suffered the past together, so let’s enjoy the future together too.
Peter Atkinson
@peteatkinson83

I do agree with Peter. Two years ago when we got promoted, if I had been told that we would be mid table in the Championship this season I would have been very pleased. That we reached the playoffs in our first season is a huge bonus, so it has all been upward and onward recently. Discussion,comment, debate and opinion is always good and other views should of course be respected, but things are looking positive, despite one or two issues. The cup performances have been disappointing and I agree that we have to sell and that this is the right way to run the club, within reason. I am a little concerned that our ability to buy skillfully in the market seems to be far reduced from what it was a few months ago, but hopefully this is just a bad/ unlucky period and the basic abilities are there within our management team. Consolidate in the championship, get the new stadium and then onward to Premier League glory. It’s in the stars!!
I’d love to hear more from Adrian. Perhaps he could write an article. What a dreamboat.
That’s all right mate, look 4 comments down and there I am again. Not sure about the dreamboat comment though!!
There is nothing going wrong at Brentford, otherwise other clubs would not be paying full market price for the riches of talent that have been developed, nor would Brentford be sitting where they are in the Table after a shocking run of injuries earlier in the season, the unfortunate Manager saga and a large number of new arrivals. The Management structure improves consistently, there is an increasing level of development of Junior players from the Academy feeding up, talent ID is better than most clubs, the players are outstanding (particularly considering their ages) and financial security finally seems to be in place. Life is not easy in The Championship and the slightest slip is costly and learning is sometimes a little painful.
We are in a great place to see Premiership football in a couple of seasons and within a short space thereafter Brentford will be challenging for Europe – of that I have no doubt. I therefore suggest the focus is on the glass half full and appreciate just what is happening at Brentford – it’s called a football revolution.
I think this article puts an awful lot into perspective & is a reality check for many that’s for sure. Nobody in their right mind wants to return to the hand to mouth existence that has been our fate as Bees fans for more years than I care to remember.
I do hope however that the model being used is modified to include players leadership,motivation & physicality attirubtes as these are vital for the league we are competing.
We are playing with the Big Boys & we need to compete before we can play & currently we look a bit lightweight & that needs to be addressed.
Whilst I agree with all that has been said, my main concern is the lack of progress regarding the new stadium. Since the original planning permission was granted nothing seems to have happened and with the new stadium playing a major part in our future progression this is of concern. I think everybody will feel a lot happier and optimistic when the start of the stadium build begins.
That is a good point. What is happening with the new stadium? I know that there was an issue with one of the companies that owns or uses some of the land and that there was an appeal against the CPO, but that was some time ago now and as I recall the indications were that this would be settled very early in the new year. It does seem to have gone rather quiet on this front.
I hope we can unearth a defensive midfielder in the Toums/Douglas role. Hope the centre-halves shape up now we have lost Tarks. Regarding strikers; Lasse Vibe needs a rest. I am sure Djuricin will be a good prospect when fully fit. But why sign Hof if we aren’t going to play to his strengths? It is not fair on the lad. I agree with Michael Mulcrone; the main worry is not the squad but the new stadium project.
Is anyone able to ask the Planning Inspector to let us know his decision vis a vis the Appeal?